The Common Good

Greed in the Economy: It's the Morality, Sinner

Sojomail - September 18, 2008


No paramilitary commander operates alone. They operate with the military, and the man in charge then was General Montoya.

- Sister Rosa Cadavid, a Catholic nun in the Medellin neighborhood who has publicly denounced operations in which the Colombian military was actively cooperating with right-wing paramilitary groups -- which the U.S. has designated as terrorist organizations. As The Washington Post reports, "A former paramilitary fighter has said in special judicial proceedings that [Gen. Mario] Montoya, who heads Colombia's army, collaborated with death squads .... His testimony, along with that of at least four paramilitary commanders, is illuminating the links between Colombia's potent, U.S.-backed military and its brutal paramilitary proxies." (Source: The Washington Post)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail


Greed in the Economy: It's the Morality, Sinner

Everyone has heard the famous phrase, attributed to James Carville, which supposedly won the 1992 presidential election for Bill Clinton: "It’s the economy, stupid!" It’s still good advice, especially as the shocking collapse of the financial markets has turned the election campaign into a much more serious and somber discussion than lipstick on pigs.

But the issue is deeper than just the economy. I would now rephrase Carville and say, "It’s the morality, sinner!" And I would direct it to the people who have been making the decisions about the direction of this economy from Wall Street to Washington. Here is the morality play:

Aggressive lending to potential home-buyers using subprime and adjustable rate mortgages led to "mortgage-backed securities" being sold to investors at high returns. As housing prices dropped and interest rates rose, homeowners got caught, fell behind on payments, and millions of foreclosures followed. That resulted in the mortgage-backed assets losing value with banks unable to sell the securities. So the subprime lenders began to fail. Asset declines then spread to investment banks. We have now seen the sale of Bear Stearns brokered by the government, and last week the government took over Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac as mortgage defaults threatened them. Then Lehman Brothers fell into bankruptcy and Merrill Lynch was sold. Now another bailout, this time of AIG, the largest insurance company in the country -- whose potential demise threatened the whole financial system even further.

During the height of the lending frenzy, many people got very rich, as they did during the previous technology bubble. Now with the collapse, experts say the most likely result will be further tightening of credit and lending standards for consumers and businesses. Home, retail, and business loans will become more expensive and harder to secure. And the consequences of that will spread to most of America.

In the accounts and interpretation of these events, a word is slowly entering the discussion and analysis — greed. It’s an old concept, and one with deep moral roots. Even venerable establishment economists such as Robert Samuelson now say, "Greed and fear, which routinely govern financial markets, have seeded this global crisis ... short-term rewards blinded them to the long-term dangers."

The people on top of the American economy get rich whether they make good or bad decisions, while workers and consumers are the ones who suffer from all their bad ones. Prudent investment has been replaced with reckless financial gambling in what some have called a "casino economy." And the benefits accruing to top CEOs and financial managers, especially as compared to the declining wages of average workers, has become one of the greatest moral travesties of our time.

In the search for blame, some say greed and some say deregulation. Both are right. The financial collapse of Wall Street is the fiscal consequence of the economic philosophy that now governs America — that markets are always good and government is always bad. But it is also the moral consequence of greed, where private profit prevails over the concept of the common good. The American economy is often rooted in unbridled materialism, a culture that continues to extol greed, a false standard of values that puts short-term profits over societal health, and a distorted calculus that measures human worth by personal income instead of character, integrity, and generosity.

Americans have a love-hate relationship with government and business. The climate seems to shift between an "anything goes" mentality and stricter government regulation. The excesses of the 1920s, leading to the Great Depression, were followed by the reforms of Franklin Roosevelt.

The entrepreneurial spirit and social innovation fostered by a market economy has benefited many and should not be overly encumbered by unnecessary or stifling regulations. But left to its own devices and human weakness (let’s call it sin), the market too often disintegrates into greed and corruption, as the Wall Street financial collapse painfully reveals. Capitalism needs rules, or it easily becomes destructive. A healthy, balanced relationship between free enterprise on the one hand, and public accountability and regulation, on the other, is morally and practically essential. Government should encourage innovation, but it must also limit greed.

The behavior of too many on Wall Street is a violation of biblical ethics. The teachings of Christianity, Judaism, and other faiths condemn the greed, selfishness, and cheating that have been revealed in corporate behavior over decades now, and denounce their callous mistreatment of employees. Read your Bible.

The strongest critics of the Wall Street gamblers call it putting self-interest above the public interest; the Bible would call it a sin. I don’t know about the church- or synagogue-going habits of the nation’s top financial managers, but if they do attend services, I wonder if they ever hear a religious word about the practices of arranging huge personal bonuses and escape hatches while destroying the lives of people who work for them. We now need wisdom from the economists, prudence from the business community, and renewal courses on the common good from the nation’s religious leaders. It’s time for the pulpit to speak — for the religious community to bring the Word of God to bear on the moral issues of the American economy. The Bible speaks of such things from beginning to end, so why not our pastors and preachers?

+ Respond to this article on the God's Politics Blog


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

My Struggle with New Monasticism
by Chanequa Walker-Barnes
I am grateful to Jason and Vonetta Storbakken for sparking this conversation and for all those who have responded. For about four years now, my husband and I have continually struggled with an ever-strengthening call to New Monastic life. Perhaps, then, the best way for [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Vote Out Poverty: ‘That’s Just How We Roll Around Here’
by Alan Clapsaddle
I dropped by the office at Discovery Church on Orange Avenue in Orlando yesterday to deliver some posters and flyers for the Poverty Sunday premiere of the film Ordinary Radicals. A leader from the young adult ministry came out to greet me. After introducing herself, she apologized for not having much time, but she [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Fair Questions for Sarah Palin
by Jim Wallis
After Sarah Palin was selected by John McCain as the Republican vice-presidential candidate, reporters asked me whether the pick was desperate, brilliant, or risky. I said, “yes.” Only time will answer the question about the wisdom of McCain’s choice. But soon after the announcement, the firestorm began. I said that it was a double standard [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Hispanic Heritage Month, Immigration, and the Presidency
by Gabriel Salguero
This week is significant in the lives of the more than 40 million Hispanics in the United States in that it marks the beginning of Hispanic Heritage Month. Just like February and March celebrate African-American and women’s contributions to the U.S., from Sept. 15 to Oct. 15 we celebrate and honor the contributions of Latinos and [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Just the Facts
by Jim Wallis
Most of you are too young to remember Joe Friday, the tough inner-city police sergeant on the old television series Dragnet, which I still see sometimes in syndication. The no-nonsense cop was famous for a line he almost always used while conducting his investigations into a crime. To the many eyewitnesses he would interview, he [...]
Continue reading this entry »

A Colombian Peacemaker’s ‘Option for Civil Resistance’
by Janna Hunter-Bowman
We are deeply concerned. Attempts are being made to link Héctor Mondragón to the FARC guerilla movement in Colombia’s paper of record, El Tiempo, which has reported on alleged e-mails to Héctor found on the computer of assassinated FARC leader Raul Reyes. Héctor, a Mennonite economist dedicated to the cause of the poor, is a good personal friend. He [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Beyond Just War Theory
by Valerie Elverton Dixon
Just War theory is a mode of analysis that lists criteria by which war may be considered righteous before, during, and after its execution. The criteria to consider before a war are: declared by legitimate authority, just cause, right intent, reasonable hope of success, last resort, and announcement. The criteria to consider during war are: non-combatant immunity, proportionality of damage to good that will result, and limitations on weapons and tactics. Young scholars in [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Ohio After Ike: On the Ground, in the Dark
by Virginia Lohmann Bauman
Yesterday afternoon, after devastating the Texas coast, the remnants of Hurricane Ike tore through Granville and the rest of Ohio, uprooting centuries-old trees and downing power lines with hurricane-force winds. More than 1 million Ohioans lost power, and some of us may be waiting for up to a week for power to be restored. In central Ohio where I live, 455,000 remain without power at this time. The schools here are closed, and many of us are without water due to well and septic systems [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Ten Reasons Why This Election Should Be about Issues and Not Personalities
by Jim Wallis
The presidential tickets in this election on both sides of the aisle have lots of “personality;” some of the candidates have even been referred to as “rock stars.” John McCain’s campaign manager, Rick Davis, has said that “this election is not about issues. This election is about a composite view of what people take away from these candidates.” That has been widely interpreted as a prediction that the election will be about personalities more than about issues. That would be a tragedy. [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Catholic Bishops Denounce Immigration Raids as Anti-Family
by Jennifer Svetlik
Last year I lived in a Catholic Worker house that offers hospitality to immigrants without first inquiring about their legal status. One day, a woman called the house on behalf of two young boys who had come home to an empty apartment [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Once Upon a Time There Was a House...
by Phyllis Tickle
Once upon a time there was a house .... Anything that begins with such words as that usually carries with it the implicit promise that a tale is about to be told. “Once upon a time” rarely is a vehicle for conveying factual or objective truth. Rather, we have learned to [...]
Continue reading this entry »

Jesus Convinces Some Evangelicals to Reject Torture
by Jimmy McCarty
Based on some responses to my last post, and a new poll by Faith in Public Life and Mercer University, it seems there are many evangelicals who believe that there are in fact times when torture is necessary and proper. I am assuming these people also believe it is at [...]
Continue reading this entry »

One Day, I Will Join the NRA
by Tim King
This week, The New York Times ran an editorial about H.R. 6691, follow-up legislation to the June Supreme Court decision on D.C.’s gun ban. After reading the editorial, I made a resolution: [...]
Continue reading this entry »

‘Meaner Streets’ in D.C.
by Elizabeth Denlinger
Even though we don’t often weigh in on local D.C. political issues, the Sojourners policy team made an exception on a new piece of legislation that would have a direct impact on gun violence in the District. We signed Sojourners on to a faith-group letter last week opposing the bill described in this [...]
Continue reading this entry »

In the Band without Leading It
by Sam and Rosalee Ewell
Greetings from Brazil! Rosalee and I have been following this exchange closely even if from afar – or à distância. A few of our friends in the U.S. — including Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove, Ángel Gallardo (who has lived at both Simple Way and Rutba House), [...]
Continue reading this entry »


The God's Politics Blog has Moved!

After two years of a blog partnership between Sojourners and Beliefnet, we're moving the God's Politics Blog in-house to the Sojourners Web site. You can still go to, which has been redirected to reach us at our new location.

Other than a new look and feel, you'll still find the latest commentary by Jim Wallis and friends "articulating the biblical call to social justice," as our Sojourners mission statment says. You will also find a few welcome changes and great new features.

+ Click here to learn more about the new and improved God's Politics Blog


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Churches asked to participate in Poverty Sunday
There are more than 2,000 verses in the Bible that focus on caring for the poor and needy. And next month, organizers of Poverty Sunday are encouraging pastors to spend some time focusing on those passages. "We're not endorsing any particular candidates or parties. We're just asking that pastors preach on how Christ calls us to take care of the least among us," said Jason Gedeik, spokesman for Sojourners. +read more

Faith leaders to candidates: Stop neglecting Gulf Coast
Associated Baptist Press

Religious leaders call for prompt and just rebuilding after storms
Worldwide Faith News

Prayers offered at Capitol for poverty to become a campaign issue
Catholic News Service

Top U.S. Religious Leaders Press for Moral Hurricane Response
The Christian Post

High-profile interfaith group calls for more help for Gulf Coast
The Dallas Morning News religion blog

Both conventions embrace religion
Reading Eagle

The Democrats’ Platform Plank on Abortion: One Step Forward and Two Steps Back?
The Christian Post

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.


American Baptist Seminary of the West is seeking a president to lead a multicultural, multiracial theological school in the ecumenical context of the Graduate Theological Union. Apply to Rev. Dr. H. James Hopkins, Presidential Search Committee, ABSW, 2606 Dwight Way, Berkeley, CA 94704.

Come to Rosedale Bible College's third Evangelical Anabaptist Symposium, November 13-15: "Following Christ: Discovering a Vital Biblical Anabaptism," featuring speakers John Roth and Jonathan Sauder. Visit for more information. Rosedale is near Columbus, Ohio.

Sojourners Job Openings Sojourners seeks qualified applicants for a variety of positions in our growing work to articulate the biblical call for social justice. Click here to learn more.

God's Politics Blog facebook
MySpace YouTube

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.