The Common Good

The Moral Core of the Health-Care Debate

Sojomail - August 20, 2009


Detention and ill treatment of protesters are being employed as a form of punishment for those openly opposing the de facto government and also as a deterrent for those contemplating taking to the streets to peacefully show their discontent with the political turmoil the country is experiencing.

- Esther Major, Central America researcher at Amnesty International, warning that Honduran authorities have resorted to mass arrests and beatings of those who support ousted President Manuel Zelaya, who was removed by a military coup June 28. (Source: Christian Science Monitor)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

The Moral Core of the Health-Care Debate

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
With all of the shouting, the fear, and now what often looks like hatred -- we are in danger of losing the moral “core” of this health-care debate. That core, quite simply, is that many people are hurting from a broken health-care system. They include the 46 million who have no health insurance, but also the many who do but don’t get what they need and simply can’t afford good health.

Yesterday afternoon, Sojourners and a broad coalition of faith-based organizations hosted a conference call to confront and offer an alternative to the fear. The 140,000 people of faith who called in are proof that our country is desperate for a message of hope and that it is the faith community that must lead the way. President Obama joined us on the call and recognized this role when he said, “Time and again, men and women of faith have shown what is possible when we are guided by our hope and not our fear.” It is high time to put that hope to work.

The call was a clear picture of the depth and breadth of the faith community's unity around the moral principle of accessible, affordable, quality care for every American -- for all of God’s children. Local pastors told moving and compelling stories about their own parishioners and people they minister to every day -- showing the critical need for health-care reform. Melody Barnes, domestic policy council director, answered questions about some of the ins and outs of the president’s plan and addressed cost issues, abortion, and conscience protections for medical workers.

We were reminded of the people the policy is meant to serve through stories about those without coverage, those who have lost coverage, and those who are worried they will no longer be able to afford the good coverage they currently have. It seems that everyone has a story, even those with health insurance, about struggling to keep up with costs, concerns about losing coverage, or being unable to afford needed care.

Most importantly, we heard from faith leaders across the country who are taking action on health-care reform in their neighborhoods, churches, mosques, and synagogues. Rev. Adam Hamilton of Church of the Resurrection in Kansas will host a forum that will include medical professionals, ethicists, and insurance executives. Lay leaders are joining together to write op-eds and letters to the editor in Missouri, and a Catholic congregation in Colorado is hosting a documentary screening and discussion night at their church.

These actions might not get the press that carrying semi-automatic rifles to one of the president's speeches or telling a Jewish congressman that he is supporting a “Nazi policy” do, but that does not mean they aren’t effective or needed. Just because fear makes a good press clip doesn't mean we should give up our hope.

We are calling on people of faith to carry on the healing ministry of Jesus by making sure your political representatives understand that the faith community will be satisfied with nothing less than accessible, affordable health care for all Americans, built on a solid financial foundation.

People of faith need to be the steady, moral drumbeat driving the debate and keeping our politicians accountable. This is a critical and long-overdue opportunity to fix a broken and inequitable system, which must not be derailed either by powerful special interests or by those, on any side, who just want to score political points. It is up to all of us to make sure that doesn’t happen.

Visit Sojourners’ health care Web site to listen to highlights of the president’s call last night and download resources on the health-care debate: This page will be updated as the debate moves forward.

Watch Jim discuss the call on MSNBC:


+ E-mail this article to friends

+ Share this article on Facebook

+ Respond to this article on the God's Politics Blog


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Three Responses to a Conservative Critic on Health-Care Reform
by Brian McLaren

I hope we can model a civil conversation on this -- as you know, there is a lot of scary miscommunication going on this summer! Let me respond on three points.
+ Click to continue

Life, Liberty, Happiness, and Health Care
by Valerie Elverton Dixon

The founding document of the United States does not say: "That to secure these rights insurance companies and employers are instituted among Men." When we understand that health care is a human right, we understand that the security of this right is an obligation of government.
+ Click to continue

An Essential Point in the Health-Care Debate
by César Baldelomar

We need a complete overhaul in the way medical and pharmaceutical professionals perceive biology and the role of medicine. This overhaul will not occur unless doctors and other medical professionals stop viewing the human person as a machine that can be fixed only through constant use of drugs and procedures.
+ Click to continue

New Martyrs in El Salvador
by Becky Garrison

This is the land of Oscar Romero, where the Maryknoll sisters and Jesuit priests were killed as well .... People of faith admire these martyrs' stories, but how will they respond to today's tragedies?
+ Click to continue

Court-martialed for Christian Conscience
by Logan Laituri

Too often service members are not made fully aware of their rights under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. Sgt. Travis Bishop, out of Ft. Hood, Texas, came to the understanding that war went against his Christian beliefs. Tragically, he was forced to walk the lonely road of doubt and uncertainty, plagued by thoughts of betraying his convictions in order to serve our country.
+ Click to continue

Breath: A Poem for Transformational Action
by Lisa Sharon Harper

Transformational development is the kind of development that does not only seek to transform the infrastructure of societies, but pays special attention to the development and nurture of human dignity in ones who have carried the crushing weight of poverty in our world.
+ Click to continue

Clinton's Africa Trip and Tutu's Legacy
by Nontando Hadebe

South Africa is an example of an intentional political commitment to a process of ensuring that representation of women in all levels of society happens. Clinton took time to address women's issues in addition to other pressing political concerns, such as the situation in Zimbabwe and HIV and AIDS.
+ Click to continue

The Truth about Immigrants and Health-Care Reform
by Allison Johnson

As town hall meetings continue to dominate the national news, I am increasingly frustrated when I hear how "illegal aliens" are draining our health-care resources. I was encouraged to read a "reality check" from the Immigration Policy Center about the reality of immigrants and our current health system.
+ Click to continue

Interfaith Health-Care Reform
by Katherine Marshall

Hospital waiting rooms are glum places pretty much everywhere. People, sick or injured, wait and wait and wait. Nowhere are the huge gaps between rich and poor so graphically in evidence.
+ Click to continue

Eat That
by Neeraj Mehta

I wonder, what do you see when you go to the grocery store? Behind all those boxes, what is really there? Behind those boxes is no longer the quaint family farm our nostalgic tendencies would have us believe. Instead, what is behind those boxes, and the meat wrapped in plastic, is a big ugly factory.
+ Click to continue

Desire, Incorporated
by Elizabeth Palmberg

Well, glory be -- the cover story of the new issue of Sojourners is all about sex. As often happens, there's more to the article than fits in the title. In addition to advocating Sex Without Shame, the writer also criticizes the fact that there are more adult sex shops in the U.S. than McDonald's ...
+ Click to continue

Liberty in North Korea
by Jeannie Choi

It's been more than a week since journalists Laura Ling and Euna Lee returned to American soil, and the entire world is waiting on baited breath to hear their stories .... What has been lost in all the media hubub regarding their return, however, is the plight of those they left behind -- the millions of ignored or forgotten North Koreans suffering from the worst human rights violations imaginable.
+ Click to continue

In the Culture War, Justice Loses
by Aaron Taylor

I get daily reports from my Christian friends in Pakistan and, as far as I can tell, what's happening is eerily similar to the anti-Christian violence that took place in India last year where, according to Asia News, around 500 people were killed.
+ Click to continue

Christian Hospitality in Phnom Penh
by Chris Baker Evens

A handful of Christians living in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, are making use of the age-old nonviolent practice of hospitality to 60 community representatives who suffer constant threats and intimidation as they work to protect land, fisheries, forests, and waterways from development projects that are more likely to entrench poverty than alleviate it.
+ Click to continue


Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Can Students Learn Without Books? A Maryknoll Sister eases frustration at a school in East Timor.

Sunday looms! Have you finished your sermon yet? Sign up for Preaching the Word sermon prep and see what Becky Garrison and Brian McLaren have to say about the Revised Common Lectionary this week. Buy now!

Let your laptop speak with the words of Micah 6:8 -- Act Justly, Love Mercy, Walk Humbly. Get your reusuable, long-lasting Sojourners Laptop Skin today. Click here.

What the Waters Revealed: Christians and Hurricane Katrina. Explore the impact of Hurricane Katrina and the breaking of the New Orleans levees in this four-part study guide from Sojourners. Available for immediate download.

Follow Sojourners on Twitter.

Good News for Troubled Times. Sojourners has resources and study guides on the economy to help you understand and get through these tough times. Click here to see the various titles available.

God's Politics Blog facebook
MySpace YouTube

Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.