The Common Good

Glenn Beck Attacks Churches on Climate Change

Sojomail - May 20, 2010


The 8 p.m. hour in cable news world is currently driven by the indomitable Bill O’Reilly, Nancy Grace, and Keith Olbermann. Shedding my own journalistic skin to try to inhabit the kind of persona that might co-exist in that line-up is simply impossible for me. It is not who I am or who I want to be.

- Prime-time anchor Campbell Brown explaining why she’s leaving CNN. (Source: The New York Times)

+ Sign up to receive "Verse and Voice" - our daily quote and Bible verse e-mail

Hearts & Minds by Jim Wallis

Glenn Beck Attacks Churches on Climate Change

Get a free trial issue of Sojourners Get a free issue of Sojourners
Donate to Support Sojourners
Donate to support

I thought Glenn Beck must have moved on to other things, but the other night, he went back to his attack on social justice churches. This time the issue was climate change.

I continue to ask Beck for a two-way conversation about this very important issue -- the biblical meaning of social justice. But so far he hasn’t been willing to talk. So I went ahead with our dialogue without him when he took up the subject of immigration. So let’s call this dialogue #2, still without brother Beck.

One of the major stories dominating the news, of course, is the worsening oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The spill is growing, with the first oil now washing into the Louisiana coast marshlands, and fishing now prohibited in 19 percent of the Gulf. Fears are that the oil will reach the Florida Keys, then enter the Gulf Stream and move up the East Coast.

This deepening disaster simply underscores the need for real energy and climate legislation that can begin to wean us from our addiction to oil, which I wrote about last week. One significant part of such legislation is new efforts to encourage buildings that are more energy efficient -- “green” buildings -- even including churches.

Yet, to Glenn Beck, this is socialism, as is everything he doesn’t agree with politically. So he said this week that “churches are being used by progressives to help bring about the fundamental transformation of America.”

Beck attacked the President’s Advisory Council on Faith-based and Neighborhood Partnerships, on which I served:

If I had told you five years ago that this government would bypass the Congress -- and thus you -- and go through the EPA to get climate change done, by having them declare that when you exhale you poison the air, you wouldn't have believed it.

And, if I had added that the government is going to merge with churches under Democrats, you'd have said I was stark raving insane ... Your church is being attacked through a faith-based initiative headed up by Barack Obama's Administration ... churches are being used by progressives to help bring about the fundamental transformation of America.

He went on to say:

Obama's Advisory Council on Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships recently issued its report of recommendations and the Obama administration is about to take faith-based initiatives to a whole new level. The president's council envisions the government and religion partnering to push the good news of global warming, climate change and green issues. Yes, the religion of environmental and social justice ... Your church is either for socialist government or the living of the gospel and you need to know which one they are teaching.

It is actually the other way around -- the faith community is pushing the government, rather than the government using us. The section of the Council’s report on “Environment and Climate Change” noted that:

There is a new and unprecedented wave of interest in environmental sustainability and climate change among America’s diverse religious communities and in neighborhoods across the country. Faith- and other community-based nonprofit institutions are in the unique position of serving as visible examples to the community. Houses of worship can exert a powerful influence when they practice good energy stewardship and preach and teach about conservation as a moral value, it has a powerful influence.

We don’t call that socialism, we call it stewardship of God’s creation. “Creation care” has become a mainstream concern among Evangelical, Catholic, and Mainline churches alike -- especially for a new generation of Christians. The recommendations of the President’s Council went on to say:

The importance of engaging with religious organizations in addressing climate change and environmental concerns has become even clearer -- as has the importance of faith-based organizations taking a prominent leadership role in influencing policy, education, and action in those areas. The more than 370,000 houses of worship alone provide locations for information to be shared, training to take place, and modeling of best environmental practices to occur.

You see, Glenn, most of our faith traditions believe that God created this earth, proclaimed it good, and gave us the mandate to serve and protect it. Yet, for thousands of years, we have abused and destroyed it. It is our role as stewards of creation that spurs us to take leadership in urging the government to do its part. This is a biblical concern of ours, not a Marxist one as you keep suggesting.

Glenn, this line of attack against the faith community is a wrong one for you. I thought you might have realized that in the flood of responses from so many pastors and church leaders (including your own Mormon church) to your earlier accusations that social justice is “code” for Marxism, socialism, and Nazism. You’re wrong, and I thought you were beginning to see that. But I guess I was wrong, as you have gone on the warpath again against the community of faith. This is about our faith, not our politics; and the truth is that your attack is really just about your politics.

If caring for creation, addressing poverty, and fixing our broken immigration system are part of the “fundamental transformation” that you are talking about, then yes, churches are being used to help bring about fundamental transformation -- but they are being used by God, not politics. So if you are going to keep up your assault on the gospel commitment to justice that we have in our churches, please be honest enough and courageous enough to have the open and public dialogue I invited you to several weeks ago. Why are you afraid of that conversation when it’s a two- way discussion? Perhaps you know that it’s not our political ideology that would be revealed, but yours. The offer still stands, Glenn. Let’s talk.

+Click here to tell Glenn Beck you’re a social justice Christian

E-mail Email this article to friends
Facebook Share this article on Facebook
Comment Comment on this article on the God's Politics Blog


Dethroning King Coal

Sojourners MagazineMountaintop removal, in which companies blow up mountains with dynamite to access coal, has destroyed more than 3 million acres of mountains, 1.5 million in West Virginia alone. In April, the Environmental Protection Agency announced rules that could significantly reduce mountaintop-removal mining in the U.S. For longtime activists like Allen Johnson, co-founder of the group Christians for the Mountains (CFTM), it’s proof that “hope is not always in vain” -- but only one step of a long journey toward environmental and economic justice in coal-mining areas of Appalachia.

+Read the Sojourners magazine article about King Coal’s destruction of West Virginia, and our web exclusive interview with Allen Johnson.


Sustaining the Movement for Creation Care

Congress has heard from government officials and BP executives about the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. We think it’s time they heard from the people and clergy who are most affected -- from vulnerable communities in the Gulf area.

Tomorrow, May 21, Sojourners will be joining with Oxfam America to sponsor a briefing for congressional staffers on Capitol Hill. Advocates from faith, community, and environmental groups from across the Gulf Coast will share their stories from those who have been most impacted by the oil spill.

If you’re in the D.C. area, you’re welcome to join us at 11:30 a.m. at the United Methodist Building (100 Maryland Ave. NE ) for a briefing for non-governmental organizations; the congressional briefing will follow at 1 p.m. in Room 406 of the Dirksen Senate Office Building.

Sojourners is also inspiring personal and communal transformation on climate change and other social justice issues. More than 2,000 people support this work as members of our <?xml:namespace prefix = st1 />Sustainers Circle. Click here to join us!


+ See what's new on the blog of Jim Wallis and friends

Video: A Second Grader's Challenge to Michelle Obama on Immigration
by Allison Johnson

This exchange between a small schoolgirl and one of the most powerful women in the world strikes me because of the beautiful yet tragic imbalance of power.
+ Click to continue

Responding to a Shocking Image of the Gulf Oil Spill's Scope
by Justin Fung

NASA released a new image yesterday that shows a large column of oil heading from the Deepwater Horizon rig site in the Gulf of Mexico out into the open ocean, a startling and heartbreaking indicator that this tragedy is far from over.
+ Click to continue

New Study Reveals Deepening Racial Wealth Gap
by LaToya Brown

The Institute on Assets and Social Policy at Brandeis University recently released their research on black and white wealth disparities. The data shows that over a 23-year period of time (1984-2007), white people's wealth quadrupled in comparison to black people's wealth.
+ Click to continue

'What the Arizona?': Silence is not an Option in the Immigration Debate
by Eugene Cho

One thing that is clear to me is that no matter where you might "stand" on the issue, silence should not be an option but from my view (and I can be wrong), the church -- especially evangelical Christian churches and its leaders -- have been mostly silent. While I know that many are still "waiting" to receive and research more details and "praying" about how to respond, don't just pray and wait -- and remain silent.
+ Click to continue

Why Glenn Beck is a Danger to True Evangelical Theology
by Efrem Smith

Glenn Beck's show on social justice and the church included guests from Liberty University and Westminster Theological Seminary who stated that the gospel is individualistic in nature. This is a very limited and unbiblical view of salvation.
+ Click to continue

A Psalm for Mine Worker Justice
by Kim Bobo

I read through psalm after psalm searching for the "right" one to read at the opening of the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA) protest near the Massey Energy shareholders meeting. The search took a while because there were too many choices -- too many psalms that spoke directly to the anger, frustration, and betrayal felt by mine workers.
+ Click to continue

Christian Zionism: Theology that Legitimates Oppression
by Tony Campolo

The most serious threats to the well-being of the Palestinians in general, and to the Christian Palestinians in particular, come not from the Jews, but from Christian Zionists here in the United States.
+ Click to continue

Civility: The Problem of Being Nice
by Diana Butler Bass

In March, I signed The Civility Covenant issued by the folks at Sojourners. Believe it or not, the Civility Covenant wound up being somewhat controversial as critics from both the political right and left attacked the document. From the left, commenters said that calls for civility are nothing more than tactics to protect white male privilege. From the right, pundits claimed that it was a whitewash to cover up conservative dissent and a cover for heresy.
+ Click to continue

Iran's Nuclear Deal: A Success for Sanctions Diplomacy
by David Cortright

The nuclear fuel swap deal signed between Iran and Turkey and Brazil is a positive development that deserves U.S. support. Rather than expressing skepticism, the White House should be offering encouragement. If implemented, the deal will reduce the immediate danger of nuclear proliferation in the region, lowering the nuclear risk to Israel and neighboring states.
+ Click to continue

What is the Gospel?
by Julie Clawson

The gospel, the good news, is about so much more than an economic transaction where I get a ticket to heaven in exchange for intellectually assenting to an idea about Jesus.
+ Click to continue

Don't Let the Banks Buy Congress
by Ben Lowe

Last year the finance industry contributed $500 million to political campaigns: that's $1.4 million dollars a day to grease the skids of American democracy; nearly $1 million per member of Congress.
+ Click to continue

New Research on Why Nonviolence Works
by Rose Marie Berger

Data backs up what nonviolent strategists already know: it's better than violence and more effective.
+ Click to continue

The Myth of Out-of-Control Border Violence
by Ian Danley

There has not been a single murder in the border town of Nogales, Arizona, for two years! FBI statistics show that crime rates in Nogales, Douglas, Yuma, and other Arizona border communities have remained flat for the past decade.
+ Click to continue

Pedagogy of the Oppressor: Arizona's Ethnic Studies Ban
by César Baldelomar

With this history (and daily reality) of oppression for non-Anglo peoples, some still have the nerve to decry ethnic studies that expose students to the history and structures of injustices.
+ Click to continue

King Coal: Ruling Principality and Power in West Virginia
by Allen Johnson

"King Coal" is the proud nomenclature for the coal industry that rules West Virginia. For the past 130 years King Coal has been my state's driving economic, cultural, political, and (I will contend) spiritual force.
+ Click to continue


+ Sign up to receive our "Daily Digest" e-mail - the latest headlines on critical issues

Top Stories:

Who is Elena Kagan?
Christianity Today blog
Jim Wallis, president of Sojourners, said that the U.S. has an addiction to oil. "At a deep level, what's not working in the U.S. is our lifestyle—particularly the consumerist energy habits we showcase to the rest of the world. Moving toward a 'clean energy economy' will require more than just a re-wiring of the energy grid; it will also take a re-wiring of ourselves—a conversion, really, of our habits of the heart. We must adjust our expectations, demands, and values," he said. +Click to continue

Study explores how nonviolence is more effective than violence
Ekklesia (United Kingdom)
A fascinating paper has been published by Maria J. Stephan and Erica Chenoweth (HT to Rose Marie Berger writing for Sojourners in the US) on how nonviolence seems more successful than violent strategies in challenging regimes. +Click to continue

"Sojourners in the news" articles are the most recent news clippings that mention Sojourners in any way - whether favorably or unfavorably. Though we provide the text on our site for your convenience, we do not necessarily endorse the views of these articles or their source publications.

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Click Here!

Faith and Finances: Christians and the Economic Crisis. Sojourners’ new discussion guide gives a faithful perspective on money, power, and stewardship. Great for Sunday school classes, small groups, sermon preparation. Download now.

An Award-Winning Magazine: Sojourners was recently named best general interest magazine by both the Associated Church Press and the Evangelical Press Association. Subscribe today!

Is God green? What does the Bible tell us about protecting the earth? Find out with Sojourners’ four-part study guide, Christians and the Environment. Learn more.

Click Here!

GIVE TO SOJOURNERS: Donate now to support this voice for justice and peace.

GET THE MAGAZINE: Subscribe today

CONTACT US: General inquiries: | Advertising: | About Us

PRIVACY NOTICE: Sojourners won't trade, sell, or give away your e-mail address. Read our privacy policy.